
A new Housing Conditions Protocol comes into force on 30 November 2026. Landlords and tenants should focus on swift repairs, sensible compensation and proportionate dispute resolution, not expensive proceedings about every point of difference.
A practical change in emphasis
On 30 October 2026 the Master of the Rolls approved a substituted Pre-Action Protocol for Housing Conditions Claims (England). It comes into force on 30 November 2026 and is not yet in force. It puts alternative dispute resolution, urgent hazards and Awaab's Law more clearly at the heart of pre-action conduct.
The previous version of the Protocol already encouraged mediation. The new text is an express reminder that ADR can be attempted at any stage and that the court can order it once litigation begins. Mediation is not newly compulsory in every housing claim.
Churchill and the existing power to order ADR
In Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council [2023] EWCA Civ 1416, the Court of Appeal held that courts can order parties to participate in an appropriate non-court dispute resolution process, including by staying proceedings, where proportionate and consistent with an effective right to a judicial hearing.
CPR amendments effective 1 October 2024 reflected this approach: CPR 1.4(2)(e) and 3.1(2)(o) expressly envisage ordering ADR. The replacement Protocol does not create the power. It places that established principle directly before housing practitioners.
Participation can be required; agreement cannot. A court can order the parties to engage in ADR, but it cannot force them to settle. A properly designed mediation preserves the right to proceed to a hearing if there is no settlement. The process must also be appropriate: a dangerous hazard requiring immediate protection should not be left unresolved while mediation is arranged.
What is actually changing?
The revised paragraph 4.1 states that ADR can be used at any pre-action stage and acknowledges post-issue court orders. New paragraphs 1.6 and 1.7 recognise urgent exceptions and confirm the Protocol never justifies a landlord's delay in complying with statutory duties.
A landlord will normally respond to a Letter of Claim within 20 working days. This period is not new, but urgent cases require a shorter reasonable response and Awaab's Law deadlines are not overridden.
New express section 10A coverage and claim-letter information address Awaab's Law, including relevant significant and emergency hazards, investigations, safety advice, communications and works. Phase 2 of Awaab's Law expands the categories of significant hazards for social landlords on the same commencement date.
The expert and joint inspection framework largely remains, with a continuing emphasis on proportionate evidence and schedules of agreed and disputed works.
Why housing mediation is well suited to practical outcomes
A court is equipped to determine legal duties and award remedies. Yet many housing condition disputes contain a series of practical questions: what investigation is necessary, what repairs are effective, who will grant access and when, how to manage disruption or temporary accommodation, what compensation is due for past inconvenience, and what costs should be paid. Those issues can often be separated and resolved in stages, rather than treated as a single all-or-nothing claim.
For example, two surveyors may agree the source of water ingress is repaired, but disagree about whether a limited section of flooring should be replaced or an adjoining undamaged room should be renewed for continuity. A focused discussion could agree the immediate works and a contingency for further replacement if opening-up shows concealed damage or a satisfactory finish cannot be achieved. The parties need not wait for a trial merely to establish that a sensible inspection or provisional repair can be undertaken. This is a hypothetical illustration, not a client case.
A practical five-part settlement agenda
- Immediate safety: identify any significant or emergency hazards; comply with statutory investigation and safety-work timescales independently of mediation.
- Works: agree a precise schedule, relevant technical standards, access, start and completion dates and a method for verifying work; specify who pays for further necessary defects discovered.
- Compensation: evaluate historic loss of amenity, evidenced special damages and any related injury claim separately from the contractor's repair quotation.
- Costs: take a realistic, proportionate approach to legal and expert costs. The Protocol provides for reasonable costs where a tenant's pre-action claim settles on terms justifying its pursuit, but the outcome depends on the facts.
- Default and review: set a clear process if work is delayed, new defects arise or a technical disagreement persists, including an agreed expert or follow-up mediation before further litigation where appropriate.
What solicitors and housing providers should do now
For claimant representatives: investigate notice, legal duties and quantum, flag urgency, make the property available for reasonable access, and advance a practical works proposal alongside any damages claim.
For housing providers: give a properly authorised case handler access to repair records and contractors, assess hazards without awaiting lawyers' correspondence, and put forward a realistic programme rather than a vague promise to investigate.
For both: consider a short online mediation or structured meeting with authority to decide not just money but scope of work, sequencing, attendance and settlement documentation.
Where a case is already issued, a consent stay for mediation can be practical; the court also has an express power to order ADR where proportionate. Settlement may address works, compensation and costs separately, and need not concede contested liability merely to enable necessary repairs. If immediate interim court relief is required for safety, that takes priority.
A shift from process to resolution
The 2026 Protocol does not abolish the right to sue. It encourages parties to demonstrate that court proceedings were needed. For the many housing disputes where remedial works can be agreed and remaining questions concern modest damages or technical details, early mediation may protect both tenants and landlords from cost, delay and escalation.
ProMediate offers independent civil and commercial mediation, including property mediation, and can facilitate early negotiations between landlords, tenants and their advisers, including online sessions. Request a mediation or contact us to discuss whether mediation suits your dispute. ProMediate is not the Housing Ombudsman and this is not a mandatory complaints scheme.
General information on the law in England, not advice on any individual claim. The replacement Protocol takes effect on 30 November 2026. Checked on 19 November 2026.
Official reading
- Pre-Action Protocol for Housing Conditions Claims (England), replacement text effective 30 November 2026
- Current Pre-Action Protocol for Housing Conditions Claims (England)
- Civil Procedure Rules, Part 3
- Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council [2023] EWCA Civ 1416 (BAILII)
- Awaab's Law Phase 2: guidance for social landlords (GOV.UK)

About the author
Peter Causton
Director of ProMediate (UK) Limited — Commercial, Civil & Workplace Mediator
Founder and Director of ProMediate. An experienced independent commercial, civil and workplace mediator registered with the Civil Mediation Council, with over 100 mediations conducted since qualifying in 2009.
View Peter’s profileSuggested reading
Related areas of expertise
Mediators for this work
How we can help
Early mediation for housing condition disputes
ProMediate offers independent civil and commercial mediation and can facilitate early negotiations between landlords, tenants and their advisers, including online sessions. ProMediate is not the Housing Ombudsman and does not operate a mandatory housing complaints scheme.

