Skip to main content

Commercial Mediation

NHS clinical negligence: a £60 billion liability, but could mediation resolve more claims?

By Peter CaustonPublished 8 min read

Barrister, Civil and Commercial Mediator · Director of ProMediate (UK) Limited

Share LinkedIn Email
Illustration of an independent mediation discussion
Existing ProMediate mediation illustration; not an NHS setting and not an indication of NHS Resolution affiliation.

Renewed scrutiny of the cost of NHS clinical negligence has focused on a £60 billion provision for future liabilities. The 2025/26 official figures reveal a more complicated picture: the overwhelming majority of clinical claims are resolved before court proceedings, few reach trial, and formal mediation remains comparatively unusual. The question is not simply how to prevent litigation, but whether a wider, appropriately designed mediation programme could resolve more disputes fairly, promptly and at proportionate cost.

The £60 billion figure needs explaining

The National Audit Office reported in October 2025 that clinical-negligence liabilities had grown in real terms from £14.4 billion in 2006/07 to around £60 billion at 31 March 2025. NHS Resolution's 2025/26 annual report again places the clinical-negligence provision at approximately £60.0 billion at 31 March 2026. This is an accounting estimate of future liabilities (including claims not yet notified and ongoing payments), not £60 billion spent in a single year, and not exclusively solicitors' fees.

The cash payments are nevertheless substantial. NHS Resolution recorded £3,238.5 million in payments across its clinical schemes in 2025/26: £2,427.9 million in damages, £622.2 million in claimant legal costs and £188.4 million in NHS legal costs. Legal costs therefore totalled approximately £810.6 million. The national debate must distinguish the rights of injured patients to adequate compensation from the separate question of whether the process for resolving their claims is efficient.

Maternity claims are particularly consequential. According to the 2025/26 report, £34.7 billion—58% of the clinical-negligence provision—relates to maternity. High awards frequently reflect the lifelong care needs of seriously injured children. It would be wrong to suggest that these damages are inherently excessive merely because they are large. Preventing avoidable harm is the most effective long-term response.

How many cases actually go to court?

There is an important distinction between making a claim, issuing court proceedings and going to trial. In 2025/26 NHS Resolution received 15,236 new clinical claims and reported incidents; that figure should not be described as 15,236 new lawsuits.

During the same financial year, 11,841 clinical claims were resolved. Of these, 9,962 (84%) were resolved without issuing court proceedings, while 1,879 (16%) were resolved after proceedings had begun. These are resolved claims, rather than a cohort of the new claims received that year. Indeed, the proportion resolved before proceedings has risen from 68% in 2017/18 to 84% in 2025/26, as described in NHS Resolution's early-resolution announcement.

Only 16 clinical-negligence cases went to trial in 2025/26 (alongside 22 non-clinical trials), according to the annual report. These numbers should not be conflated with cases where court proceedings were issued. Some contested matters genuinely require a judicial determination, and some settlements, particularly on behalf of protected parties, require court approval even when the terms have been agreed. The evidence does not support the claim that most NHS cases end in a courtroom battle.

The mediation figures are striking

NHS Resolution has operated a claims mediation service since 2016. Its 2025/26 annual report records 143 claims proceeding to mediation, with 71% settling on the mediation day or within the following 28 days. The comparable figures for 2024/25 were 138 mediations and a 73% settlement rate.

From 1 August 2025 NHS Resolution contracted with three mediation providers: the Centre for Effective Dispute Resolution (CEDR), Global Mediation and Trust Mediation Limited. The appointed panel covers personal injury as well as clinical negligence claims. Trust Mediation Limited is therefore an NHS Resolution contracted mediation provider; it should not be confused with the NHS trusts themselves, and ProMediate is not claimed to be a member of that panel.

The 143 mediation figure is for the NHS Resolution mediation service, and its published headline does not identify how many were exclusively clinical-negligence rather than non-clinical/personal-injury matters. Nor is it a random sample against which the 71% settlement outcome can be projected to all NHS claims. It would be misleading to calculate a definitive clinical-negligence mediation rate by dividing 143 by 11,841. Nevertheless, the absolute number is strikingly small against the overall scale of the claims operation. That supports asking whether more suitable cases could use mediation, not asserting that mediation would resolve every dispute.

Why mediation may do more than negotiate a payment

Where treatment has gone wrong, injured patients and their families may seek an explanation, an acknowledgement of what happened, an apology, reassurance that lessons will be learned, and appropriate financial redress. A judgment can decide liability and damages, but may not address all those needs. Mediation creates a confidential, structured opportunity for families, clinicians, NHS representatives and legal advisers to speak and explore a practical resolution. Clinicians may also gain an opportunity to explain events and achieve closure. It does not replace disclosure, an honest assessment of liability, independent advice or the duty to learn from patient harm.

Mediation can be considered after the essential evidence has been exchanged, before proceedings are issued, during case management, or even late in litigation where prospects and needs have clarified. The independent mediator does not impose a decision. A settlement must be informed and voluntary and provide compensation appropriate to the individual circumstances; it should not be used to pressure vulnerable patients into accepting less than their legal entitlement.

The cost argument is strongest where the cost of pursuing a modest claim risks becoming disproportionate to its value. NHS Resolution reports that average claimant legal costs on clinical claims valued up to £25,000 reached £30,264 in 2025/26, up from £27,380 in 2024/25. That is not proof that each such claim could have been mediated successfully, but it does make early proportionate dispute resolution worthy of serious attention.

Mediation is not the only alternative

The NHS already uses direct negotiation, resolution meetings, stocktake meetings and early neutral evaluation. Its annual report says that an early neutral evaluation pilot resolved 70% of 47 participating claims. These different mechanisms need not compete: early explanation, focused exchange of expert evidence, a neutral assessment and a facilitated mediation can be used according to the case. Settlement without court proceedings does not necessarily mean formal mediation was used.

The missing information

What is not readily apparent from the public headline figures is how many clinical-negligence claims were offered mediation, how many parties declined, at what stage mediations occurred, how outcomes varied by type or value of claim, and whether mediated cases achieved lower total costs or quicker closure than suitably comparable cases resolved by other methods. Publication of these figures, with appropriate privacy protections, would permit meaningful evaluation rather than speculation. The 71% result is encouraging, but it does not in itself establish that mediation caused those settlements or prove a system-wide saving.

A more ambitious but careful approach

An evidence-led policy could encourage an early mediation suitability review in appropriate cases; provide patients with clear information and access to independent advice; make early factual explanations and expert material available; include clinicians where appropriate and with suitable safeguards; assess the needs of seriously injured and vulnerable claimants; and measure time, costs, patient experience and durable outcomes. Proper settlement approvals and the courts' supervisory role must remain in place where legally required.

The choice is not between compensating injured patients and protecting NHS resources. Both are legitimate objectives. Reducing avoidable injury must come first. Alongside that, wider and better-evaluated use of mediation could offer some patients a less adversarial route to answers and compensation, while allowing NHS funds to be directed towards care rather than unnecessary procedural expense.

About ProMediate

ProMediate offers independent civil and commercial mediation. We are not part of the NHS Resolution mediation panel. For a suitable healthcare-related civil dispute, contact us to discuss the nature of the dispute, the parties' needs and whether independent mediation is appropriate.

Figures concern England and the relevant financial years. General commentary, not advice on an individual claim. Settlement without court proceedings does not necessarily involve formal mediation; the mediation-service figures are not a clinical-negligence-only cohort.

Sources and further reading

NHS ResolutionClinical NegligenceMedical NegligenceMediationLitigation CostsTrust MediationHealthcare Disputes
Peter Causton, commercial and civil mediator and Director of ProMediate

About the author

Peter Causton

Director of ProMediate (UK) Limited — Commercial, Civil & Workplace Mediator

Founder and Director of ProMediate. An experienced independent commercial, civil and workplace mediator registered with the Civil Mediation Council, with over 100 mediations conducted since qualifying in 2009.

View Peter’s profile

Peter Causton

Barrister, Civil and Commercial Mediator

Director of ProMediate (UK) Limited

Published:

© 2026 ProMediate (UK) Limited. All rights reserved.

Share LinkedIn Email
← Back to the Knowledge Centre

Discuss independent mediation

ProMediate offers independent civil and commercial mediation and is not part of the NHS Resolution mediation panel. Contact us to discuss whether mediation is appropriate for your healthcare-related civil dispute.